Running for public office in the United States as an American Muslim has never been a walk in the park. Just ask Abdul El-Sayed. When the former Detroit Health Department director stepped onto the political stage, he didn't just bring a progressive platform and a background as a Rhodes Scholar and physician. He brought his identity, and the backlash was swift, ugly, and entirely predictable.
Yet if you talk to Muslim communities across Michigan and the broader United States, the reaction isn't fear. It's resolve. For another view, see: this related article.
The harassment and Islamophobic smears directed at Abdul El-Sayed—ranging from baseless conspiracy theories about his faith to online hate campaigns—highlight a persistent tension in American politics. Whenever a Muslim candidate gains real traction, fringe groups and bad-faith actors try to weaponize their religion against them. Honestly, it's an old playbook. What's different now is how voters, organizers, and candidates themselves are responding to it. Instead of retreating from public life, US Muslims are organizing faster, donating more, and refusing to let bigotry dictate who gets to represent them.
Who is Abdul El-Sayed and Why Did He Become a Target?
To understand why the attacks against Abdul El-Sayed hit such a nerve, you have to look at what he represents. Born in Michigan to Egyptian immigrants, El-Sayed built a career rooted in public service before ever running for office. He earned a doctorate in public health from Oxford University, taught at Columbia University, and took over Detroit's battered health department at just 30 years old, rebuilding it after the city's bankruptcy. Related coverage on this trend has been provided by NPR.
When he launched his campaign for Governor of Michigan in 2018—and in his subsequent political advocacy and public commentary—he didn't hide his faith. He leaned into it as the moral foundation for his work on healthcare access, clean water, and economic justice.
That visibility made him a lightning rod.
Opponents and right-wing media figures didn't just attack his policies on single-payer healthcare or environmental regulation. They went after his identity. Conspiracy theories circulated online falsely tying him to extremist groups, a smear tactic that has been used against prominent Muslim Americans for decades. During his gubernatorial run, Patrick Little, a known white supremacist and antisemitic Senate candidate, even targeted El-Sayed directly with hate-filled rhetoric.
It wasn't subtle. The message from these attackers was clear: a Muslim doesn't belong in the governor's mansion, or anywhere near executive power.
The Reality of Anti-Muslim Bias in American Campaigns
If you've ever worked on a political campaign or followed local elections closely, you know that mudslinging is part of the game. Every candidate gets attacked. But there's a massive difference between attacking someone's tax plan and questioning their basic loyalty to their country because of where they pray.
According to data from the Institute for Social Policy and Understanding (ISPU), American Muslims consistently report higher levels of religious discrimination than any other faith group in the country. When that bias spills into electoral politics, it takes a very specific form. Candidates are routinely forced to answer for geopolitical events thousands of miles away, or prove their "Americanness" in ways their Christian or secular counterparts never have to.
Here is what that looks like on the ground for candidates like El-Sayed and others across the country:
- The "Foreign Loyalty" Trope: Critics often frame Muslim candidates as outsiders with hidden agendas, ignoring their local roots and public service records.
- Guilt by Association: Any charity event, community mosque visit, or local endorsement gets scrutinized under a microscope to find tenuous links to controversial figures.
- Dehumanizing Online Harassment: Campaign staffers and volunteers deal with a daily flood of violent threats and slurs on social media, which rarely makes the evening news.
The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) has documented thousands of anti-Muslim bias incidents annually, noting sharp spikes during election cycles. When political rhetoric heats up, real-world harassment follows. Community centers get threatening phone calls. Volunteers knocking on doors face hostility. It's exhausting, and it's meant to make people quit.
Why US Muslims Aren't Backing Down
You might expect this kind of sustained hostility to scare a community away from politics. Why put yourself and your family through that meat grinder?
In reality, the exact opposite has happened. Watching someone like Abdul El-Sayed stand firm under fire has galvanized American Muslims, particularly younger generations. In states like Michigan—home to one of the largest Arab and Muslim populations in the United States, centered in cities like Dearborn and Hamtramck—political engagement has surged rather than stalled.
I've seen how grassroots organizing works in these communities, and the shift over the last decade is unmistakable. Twenty years ago, the instinct after an Islamophobic attack was often to keep your head down, issue a polite press release, and hope the news cycle moved on. Today, the approach is confrontational in the best way. Organizers call out the bigotry immediately, refuse to play defense on their own humanity, and pivot straight back to the kitchen-table issues voters actually care about.
El-Sayed himself modeled this approach. When confronted with smears about his faith, he didn't apologize or distance himself from his community. He talked about how his Islamic values compelled him to fight for universal healthcare, better public schools, and corporate accountability. That authenticity resonated far beyond Muslim voters. He ended up winning over 340,000 votes in the 2018 Democratic primary, finishing second and proving that a progressive, unapologetically Muslim candidate could build a massive multi-racial, multi-faith coalition in the Midwest.
The Ripple Effect Across Local and National Politics
The resilience shown during the attacks on Abdul El-Sayed didn't stay confined to Michigan. It set a blueprint.
Look at the trajectory of Muslim representation in the years since. According to Jetpac Resource Center and CAIR, the number of Muslim Americans running for and winning local, state, and federal offices has climbed steadily in every election cycle since 2016. From city council seats in Minnesota and New Jersey to state legislatures in Georgia and Texas, candidates are stepping up precisely because they saw someone else take the hits and keep standing.
When hate attacks target a high-profile figure, they inadvertently reveal the insecurity of the attackers. Bigotry relies on intimidation. Once a community realizes that the threats won't stop them from voting, fundraising, or winning seats at the table, the tactic loses its power.
Still, we shouldn't romanticize this resilience. Being "resilient" shouldn't be a prerequisite for participating in democracy. Candidates shouldn't have to budget extra money for personal security just because of their last name, and volunteers shouldn't have to brace for racial slurs when they knock on a stranger's door. The burden of fixing this doesn't belong on the targets of hate—it belongs on political parties, media outlets, and voters who need to stop treating Islamophobic smears as legitimate political debate.
How Voters and Allies Can Counter Political Hate
If you care about keeping American elections focused on actual policy rather than identity-based fearmongering, passive sympathy isn't enough. Hate campaigns thrive when mainstream voices stay quiet or treat bigotry as "just politics."
Start by paying attention to how local media and political opponents frame minority candidates. When you see a smear campaign relying on coded language or guilt-by-association tropes, call it out publicly and support independent journalism that fact-checks these claims thoroughly.
Support organizations that track civil rights abuses and train underrepresented candidates to run safe, effective campaigns, such as ISPU, Jetpac, and local civil rights coalitions. Most importantly, engage directly with the policy platforms of candidates like Abdul El-Sayed and the growing wave of Muslim public servants across the country. Judge them by their work, their integrity, and their ideas for your community—because reducing them to a headline about the hate they endure only gives the attackers what they want.