Every time a red carpet rolls out across the polished stone of Beijing or the south lawn of the White House, the pundit class groans in unison. The headlines write themselves before the aircraft engines even spool down. Pomp prevails over substance. Style over substance. Empty theater masking a diplomatic void.
It is the laziest narrative in international relations. For another perspective, check out: this related article.
For decades, foreign policy commentators have suffered from a terminal delusion. They imagine that global superpowers negotiate like corporate legal teams drafting a merger agreement in a windowless conference room in Delaware. They look for footnotes, binding treaty text, itemized tariff reductions, and meticulously synchronized communiques. When a summit between Donald Trump and Xi Jinping concludes with grand banquets, twenty-one-gun salutes, carefully choreographed photo ops, and a distinct lack of heavy binding ink on immediate structural concessions, the armchair diplomats throw their hands up. They declare the meeting a hollow spectacle.
They are completely, embarrassingly wrong. Similar analysis on this matter has been published by The New York Times.
When nations holding forty percent of the global economy and thousands of thermonuclear warheads lock horns, the pomp is not a distraction from the substance. The pomp is the substance. Every cannon blast, every twenty-course state dinner, every carefully staged walk down a colonnade is a high-frequency broadcast of relative power, domestic security, and operational resolve. If you cannot read the choreography, you cannot read the geopolitics.
The Myth of the Technocratic Treaty
To understand why the mainstream press misses the mark every single time, you have to strip away the illusion of international law. Treaties between superpowers are not self-enforcing contracts backed by a global sheriff. They are temporary equilibrium points born of mutual coercion and immediate necessity.
When Donald Trump and Xi Jinping sit across a mahogany table, neither man is worried about the fine print of a trade protocol drafted by mid-level bureaucrats three months prior. They are testing each other's structural integrity. They are measuring breathing room, political survival, and domestic backing.
Look at how the media evaluates these encounters. They judge them by the standard of a bureaucratic checklist. Did China buy fifty billion dollars of soybeans? Did the United States rollback export controls on semiconductors? When the answer is a messy, conditional maybe, the press declares the summit a failure of substance.
This view assumes that state power functions like a spreadsheet. It does not. Superpower diplomacy is closer to primate dominance signaling or corporate warfare at the highest tier. The red carpet, the honor guard, the strict adherence to protocol—these are empirical data points. They tell you who feels vulnerable, who holds the cards, and how much domestic capital each leader has to burn.
When Xi Jinping hosts an American president with absolute, imperial pageantry, he is signaling to the Chinese Communist Party apparatus that he manages the barbarian chieftain on equal terms, projecting unshakeable internal control. When Trump accepts that scale of hospitality while projecting absolute personal dominance, he is signaling to his domestic coalition that American leverage remains absolute.
Strip away the optics, and you strip away the baseline terms of engagement. Without the pomp, there is no psychological framework within which any actual deal can even be conceptualized.
The Domestic Audience is the Only Audience That Matters
The fundamental error of the technocratic critique is assuming that foreign policy is designed for foreign capitals. It is not. Every major summit is an elaborate domestic broadcast.
Consider the political architecture surrounding both leaders. Xi Jinping presides over a slowing domestic property sector, localized demographic strain, and a party apparatus that demands constant ideological reaffirmation. Every gesture during a superpower summit is dissected by millions of party cadres in Beijing, Shenzhen, and Shanghai. If Xi appears weak, deferential, or outmaneuvered on camera, his domestic position fractures.
Donald Trump operates under an entirely different, yet equally unforgiving, domestic microscope. His base expects disruption, unapologetic nationalism, and visible dominance over foreign rivals. A handshake that looks too soft or a concession that smells like traditional establishment diplomacy is political poison in the industrial heartland.
Therefore, the banquets and the pomp serve as domestic armor. They allow both leaders to project strength back home without instantly detonating negotiations on the ground.
When critics complain that too much time was spent on pageantry and too little on granular policy, they are revealing their profound ignorance of political physics. You cannot execute granular policy until the domestic political cost of compromise has been neutralized by public theater. The red carpet is the anesthetic required to perform geopolitical surgery.
The Transactional Reality of Great Men
For all the hand-wringing about the erosion of diplomatic norms, the Trump-Xi dynamic represents a return to raw, transactional realism. The post-Cold War consensus of endless multilateral summits, endless working groups, and endless bureaucratic expansion produced plenty of paper and zero structural shifts in the global balance of power.
Decades of diplomatic paperwork failed to stop the rise of a parallel economic and military superpower in Asia. Decades of joint statements failed to secure fair market access or intellectual property protection. The traditional diplomatic machine was an elaborate treadmill designed to create the illusion of progress while structural imbalances grew wider every year.
Enter the personalized, high-stakes summit. It strips away the diplomatic corps and forces two autocrats or populist executives into direct confrontation.
In this arena, personal chemistry, perceived strength, and immediate leverage are the only currencies that clear. If Trump uses a state dinner to size up Xi's willingness to absorb economic pain, that is worth ten thousand pages of bureaucratic memos. If Xi uses the grandeur of the Forbidden City to remind an American president of the multi-thousand-year span of Chinese statecraft, that is worth ten thousand academic policy papers.
The press calls this lack of substance. History calls this realpolitik.
Reading Between the Cannons
Let us look at how these summits actually move the needle, away from the television cameras and the breathless media commentary.
When two leaders meet under layers of high-stakes pageantry, the substantive work happens in the margins. It happens in the unrecorded forty-minute conversation in a side room where the translators are sworn to absolute silence. It happens when one leader leans across the table and states a red line that will never appear in a press release.
Substance in superpower relations is not a signed PDF. Substance is a shared, unspoken understanding of where the tripwires are located. It is the calibration of deterrence.
During these encounters, the pomp creates the necessary tension and prestige. It raises the stakes so high that both leaders are compelled to manage the fallout afterward. A messy, un-choreographed press conference where both men air their grievances publicly is often far more substantive than a dozen pre-cooked joint communiques written by career diplomats who haven't won an election in their lives.
The media wants a neat little deal wrapped in a ribbon because it makes for easy copy. But the world does not work through neat little deals between rival empires. It works through deterrence, signaling, and the constant, grinding test of wills.
The Real Danger of the Technocratic Delusion
The persistent insistence that pageantry is meaningless has real-world consequences. It leads political analysts to completely misread foreign intent.
When analysts focus exclusively on policy papers and missed trade targets, they miss the strategic shifts happening right in front of them. They spend months debating the exact tariff percentage on washing machines while ignoring the massive psychological shift signaled by how a foreign leader is received at the airport.
This myopia blinds the West to how the rest of the world operates. In many political cultures—particularly across Asia, the Middle East, and parts of Europe—form is function. The way power is displayed, the respect paid to hierarchy, and the public framing of relationships dictate whether agreements will hold or collapse the moment the ink dries.
To dismiss this as mere showmanship is peak Western provincialism. It is the belief that the entire planet should operate like a municipal zoning board meeting.
The Uncomfortable Truth
The next time a major summit fills your television screen with martial music, red carpets, and endless handshakes, ignore the talking heads complaining about a lack of substance. Look closer.
Watch the body language. Notice who yields the center of the frame. Listen to the subtle shifts in nationalist rhetoric before and after the cameras roll. That is where the actual governance of the planet takes place.
The pomp is not the mask hiding the void. The pomp is the weapon. And until the commentariat learns to read the language of power instead of the language of press releases, they will continue to wonder why the world keeps spinning past them while they look for footnotes that were never meant to be written.