Why Putting Bodyguards on Every Politician is a Terrible Idea

Why Putting Bodyguards on Every Politician is a Terrible Idea

The media response to the horrific vehicular attack on Australian federal MP Helen Haines has been predictably lazy. Pundits across the political spectrum are clutching their pearls, screaming about an epidemic of political violence, and demanding that local electorate offices be transformed into heavily fortified bunkers surrounded by panic buttons and private security details.

Let us be entirely clear about something right out of the gate. What happened to Helen Haines in Wangaratta was monstrous. She suffered catastrophic injuries, including the amputation of both legs, after a motorist deliberately targeted her outside her office. It is a tragedy that has rightfully shocked a nation where political violence has historically been rare.

Yet the immediate pivot toward hardening politicians against the public is a toxic overreaction that will destroy the very fabric of Australian democracy.

The lazy consensus claims that the social contract is broken and that elected officials can no longer safely mingle with the electorate without armed guards standing watch. This diagnosis gets the problem precisely backwards. The strength of Australian politics has always been its low-friction accessibility. You can walk into a local pub, run into your MP at the supermarket, or chat with them on a regional footpath without clearing a metal detector.

When you wall off politicians behind layers of private security, you do not protect democracy; you kill it. You institutionalize the exact alienation and distrust that feeds populist anger in the first place.

Look at what happens when public figures retreat behind defensive perimeters. I have spent years observing governance models across Western democracies, and every single time a state responds to civil volatility by increasing physical distance between the rulers and the ruled, public trust plummets into the negative digits. Security theater creates a psychological barrier. It signals to the average citizen that their representative is an elite class requiring special state-backed insulation from the dirty, dangerous rabble.

Furthermore, the panic-driven push for millions of dollars in taxpayer-funded security infrastructure ignores basic statistical reality. While threats against federal parliamentarians have risen—surpassing 1,000 incidents in the recent financial year—the vast majority of these threats are digital bile spewed by anonymous cowards behind keyboards. Turning a regional electorate office into Fort Knox does nothing to stop a troubled individual from weaponizing a vehicle in broad daylight. It merely gives bureaucrats a false sense of security while bleeding public coffers.

If we want to stop these incidents, we have to stop treating every violent act by an isolated individual as a systemic political insurrection. When a disturbed local rams an MP with a car, it is a criminal justice failure and a mental health crisis, not a mandate to turn Canberra’s representatives into paranoid hermits wrapped in corporate security bubbles.

Instead of building walls, we should be doubling down on community presence. We need better mental health intervention infrastructure at the local level, stricter monitoring of individuals flagged for erratic behavior, and an absolute refusal to let violent actors dictate how civil society operates.

If politicians hide behind bodyguards, they stop listening to the people. And once they stop listening, democracy is already dead.

Stop building bunkers. Face the public. Fix the actual root causes of social decay instead of treating the symptoms with expensive, cowardly architecture.

CT

Claire Taylor

A former academic turned journalist, Claire Taylor brings rigorous analytical thinking to every piece, ensuring depth and accuracy in every word.